21 Most Divisive Looks To Hit the Red Carpet in 2024 So Far

Saoirse Ronan at the 2024 Gotham Awards

Image Credit: Kristina Bumphrey

Saoirse Ronan’s Schiaparelli look at the 2024 Gotham Awards had some fans conflicted. While she looked beautiful, the rose-adorned point in the center of the neckline wasn’t universally loved. “It’s giving tree bark but a very fashionable one,” one fan wrote on Instagram. 

Jodie Turner-Smith at the 2024 Fashion Awards

Image Credit: Matt Crossick

Jodie Turner-Smith is usually right at the top of our best-dressed list, so we were certainly taken aback by her look at the 2024 Fashion Awards. Her look consisted of this sequined Burberry cream dress, a brown fur coat, her fair in twisted pigtails and a silver bag. Safe to say it was just a lot going on for fans.

Cynthia Erivo at the ‘Wicked’ Premiere in Mexico City

Image Credit: Cristopher Rogel Blanquet/Getty Images

Cynthia Erivo has proved she’s not afraid to dress on theme went it comes to her new movie, Wicked. At the Mexico City premiere on November 11, however, some fans believed this Thom Browne look with fake hands was just a step too far. 

“I love theme dressing for premieres but there’s a fine line between costume and fashion,” wrote one fan on Check the Tag on Instagram. “Ariana [Grande] and Cynthia both have been skewing too far costume I think.”

Taylor Swift at the 2024 MTV Video Music Awards

Image Credit: Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Images

Taylor Swift’s edgy tartan Christian Dior look at the 2024 MTV Video Music Awards had fans split.

Addison Rae at the 2024 MTV Video Music Awards

Image Credit: Noam Galai/Getty Images for MTV

Addison Rae attended the 2024 MTV Video Music Awards in this lingerie-inspire white look, composed of a bra, matching underwear, and a puffy tulle back, which was a custom look by Claire Sullivan.

Heidi Klum at the amfAR Gala Cannes

Image Credit: Michael Buckner/Variety via Getty Images

Heidi Klum was all smiles at the amfAR Gala Cannes in May in this peach fuzz-colored ruffled gown by Lever Couture. The look, however, was not everyone’s favorite, with some criticizing it for being shapeless and uninspired. 

“Giving worm from the back but she kinda ate,” wrote one user on Twitter.

Bella Hadid at Cannes

Image Credit: Michael Buckner/Variety via Getty Images

As one of the most beautiful and successful supermodels in the world, Bella Hadid can look drop-dead gorgeous in any look. But, when she wore this sheer look at the The Apprentice premiere at the 2024 Cannes Film Festival, fans were unimpressed. To many the nudity and the length of the dress just weren’t appropriate for such a prestigious red carpet. 

“Not for the red carpet of Cannes! Does she know where she is?” commented one user on Instagram. “Bella is gorgeous but this look for this event feels insecure and trying too hard to keep attention for all the wrong reasons,” wrote another. 

Kim Kardashian at the Met Gala

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images

Kim Kardashian left fans scratching their heads at the 2024 Met Gala in this Maison Margiela Couture silver gown with leaf-shaped chainmail and a gray shawl. After all, while she looked beautiful, and her waist was so cinched it was kind of unbelievable, everyone kept asking themselves, “Why did she wear the sweater on top?”

Explaining it to Vogue, Kardashian said the ensemble represented “the wildest night of my life in a garden,” and after her fun romp, she grabbed her “boyfriend’s sweater and threw it on and had to get to work. And my hair’s all messed up.”

Jennifer Lopez at the Met Gala

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images

Jennifer Lopez looked like her usual stunning self at the 2024 Met Gala in this bedazzled Schiaparelli gown. But, considering she was one of the night’s star-studded hosts, fans were expecting more. 

“Not that I had high expectations for her, but as co-chair, I was kind of excited to see her use this theme and have a bit of a moment but this is the same exact silhouette and glam we see on her constantly. I’m just so sad about it 😪,” wrote one fan on Instagram. “Stunning dress but starting to think either I don’t understand the theme or none of these ppl do 😂,” wrote another. 

Elsa Pataky & Chris Hemsworth at the Met Gala

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images

The same goes for Elsa Pataky and Chris Hemsworth at the 2024 Met Gala. Did they look beautiful? Sure! Did it feel like they made the effort as co-chairs? Not really. 

“This is already bad for a man but for a man that is co-chair??” questioned one user on Instagram over Hemsworth’s look. “oh nah not the basic suit,” another wrote. 

Doja Cat at the Met Gala

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images

Doja Cat left some fans furious when she showed up at the 2024 Met Gala in this custom Vetements wet t-shirt look. 

“I know that people are going to do flowers, but my flower of choice is the most-used flower. And it’s cotton,” she told Entertainment Tonight on her look. “I wanted to do a white T-shirt, also because a white T-shirt is timeless. And it felt very poetic to choose this.”

Online, fans had different reactions. “I don’t hate it!!! it’s her, it’s costumey, it’s on theme!” wrote one user. “She still thinks that this is shocking,” wrote another. “No mama, it’s just bad taste and ridiculousness.”

Emily Blunt at the Oscars

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images

For many fans, Emily Blunt’s Schiaparelli look at the 2024 Oscars was quite a disappointment, so much so that even Blunt’s stylist had to defend the look. The dress, which featured structured floating shoulders, also had silver sequins in the shape of underwear. 

“WHY ???????? Seriously why 😢,” wrote one user on Instagram. “She is so beautiful but the details that outline underwear are not flattering.”

Some rare fans, however, looked this out-of-the-box look on her. “I LOVE THIS!!” wrote another commenter. “finally a good look for her!! i dont understand the hate in the comments. This look is so different for her, so fashion forward. LOVE.”

Emma Stone at the Oscars

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images

Emma Stone, who ended up taking the Best Actress Oscar that night, also raised some eyebrows with her look. The mint green color, the peplum and the dress malfunction when she won her award were all up for criticism. 

“Design is ok but let’s be frank: that color make her look like she is wearing a tablecloth,” wrote one user on Instagram. “The color is stunning and makeup and hair are great wish the bottom was just a fit and flat or ball gown,” wrote another. “The peplum feels very 2014.”

Paris Jackson at the Elton John AIDS Foundation Oscars Viewing Party

Image Credit: Elyse Jankowski/Variety via Getty Images

Paris Jackson caused quite a stir when she Elton John AIDS Foundation 2024 Oscars Viewing Party in this mesh Giambattista Valli dress with ultra-high slits. And while some fans weren’t fans of the look, especially just how sheer it was, Jackson looked undeniably beautiful. 

“When will this massive nudity dress trend stop?” asked one user on Instagram. “Usually hate sheer but she’s rocking it!” wrote another. 

Ali Wong at the Screen Actors Guild Awards

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images

Ali Wong, who won major awards all throughout awards show season for her role in Beef, really went all out at the 2024 SAG Awards in this black and white Iris Van Herpen gown. And while some applauded her for the drama, others just couldn’t get behind the look. 

“I love iris van herpen but who thought this was a good idea? 😭 what a waste of a gorgeous dress,” wrote one user. “Great dress, but needed different hair, make-up, earrings and glasses,” wrote another. 

Billie Eilish at the SAG Awards

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images

Also at the SAG Awards, Billie Eilish got some hate for dressing too casually for the red carpet in this Vivienne Westwood look. Others, on the other hand, applauded her for sticking to her signature style. 

“I love her but it wouldn’t kill her to dress for the occasion,” wrote one Instagram user. “not to everybody’s taste but I totally get it. it’s kinda like a GenZ version of Dianne Keaton,” wrote an Eilish fan. “I’m glad Billie returned to form.

Anya Taylor-Joy at ‘Dune: Part Two’ Premiere

Image Credit: Samir Hussein/WireImage

Anya Taylor-Joy got quite a lot of people riled up when she wore this white custom Christian Dior gown and matching headscarf to the Dune: Part Two premiere in February. While some praised the actress for the elegant and minimalistic look, others accused the look of attempting to “cosplay as Muslim women,” per The Independent. 

“Is this a special “Ramadan Edition”? 🙂⁉️” one user wrote on Instagram. “This is like some Mary Magdalene thing??” questioned another. “I don’t hate it I’m just processing.” 

Emma Stone at the EE BAFTA

Image Credit: Jeff Spicer/Getty Images

Another Emma Stone look that received mixed reviews was this orange custom Louis Vuitton with a billowing one-shoulder puff sleeve.

“I love this ❤️ people are hating? How? It’s the perfect Bella/ poor things recreation, plus the color looks good on her skin,” wrote on reviewer on Instagram. “This looks like a prom dress you find on the clearance rack in June 😬,” wrote another. Ouch!

Taylor Swift at the Grammy Awards

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Billboard via Getty Images

Taylor Swift has millions of fans applauding her every move, but this white strapless Schiaparelli dress with black gloves at the 2024 Grammys wasn’t a slam dunk, even for the biggest Swifties. 

“It’s the hair, the gloves and the over abundance of necklaces. It’s all too much,” wrote one user on Instagram. “The dress is so elegant but everything else is distracting from it:/.” “One step forward (the dress),” another wrote. “2 steps back (the hair and overall styling).”

Miley Cyrus at the Grammy Awards

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Billboard via Getty Images

Also at the Grammy Awards, Miley Cyrus showed up in quite a head-turning look in this skin-baring custom Maison Margiela mesh dress. 

Among her fans, reactions were quite mixed. “If anyone can pull this look off it’s HER!” one user wrote on Instagram. “Gorgeous piece but I kinda wish she wore something else 😂,” another admitted. 

“I’m torn about it but it’s gorgeous at the same time?” another questioned. We’re not sure if they’ve made up their mind yet. 

Margot Robbie

Image Credit: Elizabeth Goodenough/Everett Collection

As we all know, Margot Robbie took the Barbie theme to heart during her press tour for the movie. At the 2024 Golden Globes, however, her look, which included this sequined custom Armani Privé gown and ruffled shawl, didn’t quite hit the mark for some fans. 

“It’s too camp for me. She’s so gorgeous and there are thousands of better dresses that could have conveyed Barbie better,” wrote one user. “I know exactly what Barbie this is,” wrote another, referring to the Superstar Barbie Robbie was emulating. “😍 loveeeee!” 

vmas-4

Image Credit: Gilbert Flores/Billboard via Getty Images, Noam Galai/Getty Images for MTV

Taylor Swift, Addison Rae