A seemingly ordinary baby shower turned into a dramatic clash of boundaries and social expectations when a Reddit user publicly refused to invite her aunt's daughter on an upcoming camping trip.
The story, shared in a post on November 19 titled "AITA for Embarrassing My Aunt at a Baby Shower Instead of Politely Declining an Invitation Request?" has amassed over 8,100 upvotes, and ignited a debate online.
The Redditor, 16, refers to her mom's best friend, "Jenny" as her aunt, even though they aren't biologically related. Despite their closeness, the poster describes a strained relationship with Jenny's daughter, Ellie, who is 16.
"Jenny is sadly the kind of mom who thinks Ellie is never wrong," they wrote. "When Ellie stole a hair ribbon from another girl, Jenny insisted the other girl was lying because she was jealous of Ellie."
Other examples include failing school assignments, which Jenny blamed on "jealous teachers," and Ellie's older sister cutting contact after moving out, which Jenny has refused to acknowledge as a significant issue.
While the Redditor's mother has noticed the same patterns, she has opted to avoid conflict, typically steering conversations away from Ellie. That strategy was tested during the baby shower, where Jenny began dropping hints about Ellie joining the Redditor's upcoming camping trip.
The situation escalated when Jenny's hints prompted the Redditor's mother to begin inviting Ellie to the camping trip. Before the invitation was even completed, the Redditor interrupted with a loud and decisive response.
"Before she finished her sentence, I loudly said, 'Oh hell no!'" the poster recounted.
The blunt rejection reportedly left Jenny visibly upset, and the Redditor's mother, embarrassed by the public scene, initially canceled the camping trip as punishment. Although she later reversed the decision, she expressed her disappointment, suggesting her daughter could have declined more tactfully.
"You could have said something like, 'Sorry, there's no room or supplies for another person,' or, 'My friends aren't comfortable with someone they don't know well coming along,'" the mother reportedly told her.
Upon reflection, the poster concludes: "I realize I could have been more respectful, but I was also trying to put a stop to that immediately. Also, we got some looks, just because I admit I was pretty loud, but everyone outside of Jenny and Mom seemed to move on almost immediately. So I think she's turning the 'embarrassment' into a bigger deal than it actually was."
'Social Opportunities Without Pressure'
Newsweek discussed the post with Charlotte Bailey, a psychotherapist specializing in helping people address the root cause of people-pleasing.
England-based Bailey said: "When children feel pressured into friendships that go against their own preferences, they may feel misunderstood or invalidated. Over time, this can erode self-esteem, as they might feel their feelings and choices don't matter. Forcing friendships can also create resentment, anxiety, and difficulty setting boundaries, which can lead to people-pleasing behaviors, where children feel obligated to maintain relationships that aren't fulfilling, a pattern that can follow them into adulthood."
The host of Let's talk People-Pleasing! podcast added: "Parents should respect their child's natural social preferences and create space for exploration of friendships that feel authentic to them. Encouraging social opportunities without pressure, modeling healthy social behaviors like conflict resolution, assertive communication, and boundary-setting, and teaching children that it's okay not to be friends with everyone, can help them build relationships based on mutual respect."
Reddit Reacts
The post quickly sparked debate on Reddit, with many commenters siding with the poster's decision to set boundaries.
One comment with 12,000 upvotes says: "NTA. A lot are going with YTA, but I'll say something about the 'hint hint, nudge nudge' crowd, especially when they're in denial; they ignore soft nos. Could you have been more polite, at least for the first one? Sure, but would it have worked? And, as this wasn't just your trip, you had a responsibility to hold the group's boundaries."
Another said: "Sometimes you HAVE to be rude, otherwise people won't get the hint. Making up excuses like 'we don't have space in the car' can mean they'll offer up their car or something like that. Definitely a bit TA, but it was necessary here. Now hopefully she won't try to get you to invite Ellie to other things."
A third commenter related: "I've been in similar situations, and setting boundaries is crucial. It's tough at 16, but you'll learn tact with time. Your mom should respect your choices too."
Newsweek reached out to u/Icy_Coconut_3052 for comment. We could not verify the details of the case.
If you have a family dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured on Newsweek.
English (US) ·