17 Movie Adaptations That Were Actually Better Than The Books

10 hours ago 1

"I honestly don't know how somebody read that story and then envisioned that movie."

Recently, u/Big_Mood8848 asked r/MovieSuggestions for movies that were better than the book they adapted, and we thought we'd share some of the most popular responses:

1. Fight Club

A group of men stand together in a dimly lit room, focusing on a central man with spiked hair and a white t-shirt, suggesting an intense scene

20th Century Fox

"The film stayed close to the book, pretty much scene for scene, but the addition of Pitt, Norton, and Bonham-Carter, along with the cool visuals, elevated the whole thing."

–RudeHelicopter4662

2. Forrest Gump

A person with a long beard and cap walks on a rural road, followed by a group

Paramount Pictures

"Forrest is vulgar in the book and actually goes to space with a chimpanzee. I could not finish it."

–Steelflight09

5. Arrival

A person stands facing large circular symbols in a misty environment, with abstract shapes resembling hands in the background

Paramount Pictures

"The story was great and filled in some of the gaps but it was definitely dry compared to the movie."

–NilesandDaphne

6. Blade Runner

Person aiming a gun in dramatic scene, wearing a jacket

Warner Bros.

"Blade Runner is a cultural touchstone. The book it was based off, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep is not bad, but does not achieve the heights of the film."

7. The Witches of Eastwick

Three women with curly hair look focused as they hold knitting needles and yarn, suggesting crafting or creating something together

Warner Bros.

"In Updike's book, the witches are ugly, unsympathetic characters, and the overall book is kind of heavy and meandering without a satisfying conclusion. The movie reimagines the story as a sexy comedy which I think is a big improvement."

–CourtCreepy6785

8. The Shining

Person with a wide smile and open hands, seated indoors with a chandelier in the background

Warner Bros.

"This might be an unpopular opinion. It's an interesting example because Stephen King himself didn't like what Kubrick did with the film, and I can certainly understand why."

–Reasonable-Banana636

9. Field of Dreams

Baseball players in vintage uniforms walking out of a cornfield with focused expressions

Universal Pictures

"Book is fine, but J. D. Salinger suing and getting his name removed from any adaptation made the movie. The dynamic between James Earl Jones ’s and Kevin Costner's characters made the movie. In the book, it’s two guys who live on farms and have a lot of similarities driving around the country. Somewhat boring, honestly."

–Sopranohh

10. The Mist

A group of frightened people, including a man holding a child, navigate through thick fog near parked cars

Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer

"I'm gonna have to say The Mist. Loved the book – went into the movie knowing it wasn't going to be great. Came out loving it. The ending was different but man did it make the movie so much better."

–Distinct_Sentence_26

11. American Psycho

Person wearing a suit and tie with headphones, standing in an office setting

Lions Gate Films[

"The film is brilliantly portrayed, but the book is outright disgusting. I've read a few Brett Easton Ellis books, and his attention to detail is incredible, but does make for some confusing chapters."

–gijoe438

12. The Firm

Two men conversing by a car. One, in a trench coat, holds a briefcase; the other, wearing a black coat and tie, looks at him intently

Paramount Pictures

"I like Grisham's stuff, but this book didn't land for me. I saw the movie and immediately thought, 'Way better.'"

–HairMetalEnthusiast

13. Requiem for a Dream

Two people in dark clothing lie on a floor covered with scattered papers, appearing thoughtful or contemplative

Summit Entertainment

"Although it isn't an easy watch, Aronofsky really took Hubert Selby Jr's book to another level and the score is brimming with energy and emotion which makes it all the more impactful."

–lamparillo

14. Hannibal

A person wearing a menacing mask holds another person in their arms, creating a dramatic scene

Universal Pictures

"The book totally jumped the shark. I wanted to tear the last chapter out. I think the movie is closer to what the character would have done. But I’m not the author. So what do I know. I just know what I liked more."

–LeePT69

15. The Postman

A person in rugged attire examines a map next to a horse on a roadside, suggesting a journey or exploration

Warner Bros.

"I unironically enjoy the movie. I liked the book, but it went way deep into weird Sci-FI territory. I liked how the movie was more realistic in how things played out."

–Fyrentenemar

16. The Milagro Beanfield War

Man in a sheriff's uniform and cowboy hat stands outdoors, looking serious. Background features a vintage advertisement sign

Universal Pictures

"It's much cleaner and more coherent than the book. It's a great movie. It's also a great, but pretty different book."

–Optimal-Ad-7074

17. Jaws

Two men on a boat labeled "ORCA" face a great white shark emerging from the water with its mouth open wide

Universal Pictures

"The movie was much tighter and the characters much better than the book."

What film adaptation do you think was better than the book? Let us know in the comments below!

Read Entire Article