We're Picky Editors—29 Holiday Gifts We're Putting on Our Wish Lists

2 weeks ago 1

published 7 November 2024

A basket that contains a loewe plaid scarf, burgundy leather gloves, a champagne bottle, a zucchini, magazines, and a red onion.

(Image credit: Who What Wear)

If there's one thing I’ve noticed about myself and my co-workers here at WWW, it's that we all share a trait: We are pretty picky when it comes to the gifts we wish to receive. As experts in the fashion and beauty spaces, we have our own unique preferences that often make gift giving a bit of a challenge. For instance, some may have a fondness for a specific beauty brand because of a signature formula, while others might strongly believe in a particular sweater because they rely on it year after year.

With the holiday season approaching, I was interested to hear what holiday gifts my colleagues were already eyeing. So I reached out to them and rounded up the top items they will most likely ask for, treat themselves to, or give to a loved one this year.

Our editors undoubtedly have good taste. So when I tell you these buys are it, I think you'll agree. The selection features an exciting mix of fashion, beauty, and wellness items: Some are the latest trends that have just hit the shelves, while others are tried-and-true staples we gravitate toward season after season. I encourage you to keep scrolling to explore this thoughtfully curated assortment of gifts.

Bobby wears a black leather moto jacket and navy printed shirt.

Soft Empire Carryall Bag 40

COACH

Soft Empire Carryall Bag 40

"I have the Coach 35 bag, and I'm so in love with it for my everyday life. I also get many compliments on it. I have my eye on the size 40 in navy or merlot for travel."

L'eau Papier - Scented Cleansing Hand and Body Gel

Diptyque Paris

L'Eau Papier Scented Cleansing Hand and Body Gel

"This Diptyque scent is one of my new favorites. The cleansing hand and body gel seems so luxurious."

Portrait of Caitie from Who What Wear

haircare

Aveda x Altuzarra

botanical repair™ strengthen & smooth styling essentials gift set

"I have a love-hate relationship with my hair. I'm pretty low-maintenance, but I still want my hair to look presentable. That's why I love this set. It comes with a wooden paddle brush that can help me detangle my long locks (and would look great on my vanity) and a styling cream that reduces frizz and strengthens hair while protecting it from heat damage. Sounds like a win in my book. Plus, the beautiful packaging is a nice bonus."

Sierra wears an orange blazer.

Tom Ford, Soleil Neige Shimmering Body Oil

Tom Ford

Soleil Neige Shimmering Body Oil

"As a fragrance lover, one of the best gifts I've gotten is this glittery body oil that pairs well with whatever my favorite scent is of the moment. It goes with any perfume in my collection that I choose to wear, and I get so many compliments on the glistening shine that it gives me."

revolve,

"I've been getting so much better sleep lately thanks to this silk eye mask, so I've been raving about it to anyone. To people who never feel like they can sleep in, I'm gifting them with this."

Nikki Chwatt wears a shell choker necklace.

(Image credit: @nikki.chwatt)

Lofty Alpaca Cardigan

Naadam

Lofty Alpaca Cardigan

"I saw this cardigan in person, and believe me when I say it's even better IRL. The alpaca wool is so soft, and the buttons look so rich."

Theraface Depuffing Wand for Under Eye Bags & Dark Circles

Therabody

Theraface Depuffing Wand

"My favorite health and wellness influencer swears by this Theraface Wand, so naturally, it went on my wish list. I'm obsessed with de-puffing my face in the morning, so I know this will help me streamline my routine."

Non-Stop Earrings

Jenny Bird

Non-Stop Earrings

"I tried these on in Jenny Bird's NYC store and immediately fell in love with them. They not only make a chic statement, but they also are lightweight, so they're comfortable for all-day wear."

Cointreau, Cosmos + Caviar Kit

Cointreau

Cosmos + Caviar Kit

"If you know me, you know that I love caviar. So when I heard about the cocktail and caviar kit created in collaboration between Cointreau and Danielle Zaslavsky, known as the 'caviar queen,' I immediately added it to my holiday wish list. The kit includes all the ingredients for a cosmopolitan, four glasses, a mother-of-pearl dish with spoons, and a tin of caviar—what more could I need?"

Yusra wears a patterned silk scarf, brown blazer, and white t-shirt.

Book Box Vol 1

Heaven Mayhem

Book Box Vol 1

"I first saw these book-shaped jewelry storage cases at Heaven Mayhem’s preview in NYC and was delighted to hear it was releasing them for sale. I love storage that still looks good sitting on a shelf, and these are a type-A fashion girl’s dream."

Brushed Cashmere Cropped V-Neck Sweater

j.crew

Brushed Cashmere Cropped V-Neck Sweater

"I don’t think you can go wrong with cashmere, and J.Crew’s brushed cashmere is special enough to be the perfect gift. Plus, look at all those fun colorways!"

kaitlyn mclintock wears a leather jacket.

Royal Pine Deluxe

Vacation

Royal Pine Deluxe

"Vacation, the skincare brand famous for its unabashed '80s aesthetic, is better known for its summer scents, but it just recently released this pine-scented candle. It features balsam pine accord, Siberian pine needle, and imported Norwegian spruce, and it's complemented with a touch of 'alpine forest terroir' and 'Swiss mountain chalet.' It's like if Wham's 'Last Christmas' music video was distilled into a candle (IYKYK)."

Maybell Claw Clip

France Luxe

Maybell Claw Clip

"I was recently introduced to France Luxe hair accessories, and I'm obsessed. Whether it's chic silk bows or sophisticated claw clips (like this one), I'm planning on gifting them to friends and family. I also wouldn't mind getting a few myself…"

Midnight Minis Lip Set

LANEIGE

Midnight Minis Lip Set

"I, like so many other beauty editors, am a big fan of the iconic Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask. I apply one of three in my nightstand every night before I go to bed. This gift set of five mini sizes—Berry, Gummy Bear, Peached Iced Tea, Mango, and Watermelon Pop—is too good not to make my holiday wish list. The jars are adorable, and I love that you can test so many flavors before committing to the full-size versions."

The Icons Collection

Perfumehead

The Icons Collection

"Perfumehead is pretty much *the* cool-girl fragrance brand. Whether it's Canadian Tuxedo or Cosmic Cowboy (the latter inspired by the Sunset Strip in the 1970s), each scent is unique, complex, and worthy of becoming your signature. The standard 50-milliliter bottles cost $4395, so this nine-piece sample collection feels like a steal for $80. It's the perfect way to explore such a sought-after perfume collection without breaking the bank."

A portrait of Anna from Who What Wear wearing a white button-down shirt and blue jeans.

Wool-Blend Cape

"Cape silhouettes were a huge theme on the most recent runways and are set to be one of 2025's key trends. This COS topper is how I plan on tapping into the look—it's so chic and forward-feeling but without the designer markup."

James Bezel 3mm, Lab White Sapphire Gold RiviÈre Necklace

Dorsey's James Bezel Necklace has lingered at the top of my wish list for a long time now, and I've been dropping subtle hints to everyone in my life about it. A tennis necklace is the ultimate investment piece that's timeless and eternally chic, and I love how the round bezel setting makes this one feel a touch more modern to wear daily and hold on to for years to come."

Judith wears a yellow v-neck sweater over a gray shirt.

Icon Watch

"This watch from Heaven Mayhem is elegant, classic, and timeless—the perfect addition to elevate my everyday looks. Santa, if you can hear me—please don't forget to put this one under the tree."

Small Eloise Earrings

Lili Claspe Jewelry

Small Eloise Earrings

"L.A.-based jewelry brand Lili Claspe just launched a collaboration with supermodel Jasmine Tookes, and I'm obsessed with everything, particularly the Small Eloise Earrings. The design is beautiful, and they're perfect to wear day or night. They're at the top of my wish list."

Caroline Bag Espresso

Freja New York

Caroline Bag Espresso

"I've been eyeing the Freja New York bags on fashion girlies for some time now and would really love to get my hands on the iconic Caroline bag in the new luxurious Espresso colorway."

Kristen wears a black tank top.

Women's Teen Lauren 1980 With Chain in Barolo

Bottega Veneta

Teen Lauren 1980

"I've been trying to find this Bottega Veneta bag on the vintage market for years, but I'm in luck now that it was reissued."

Buly, Capri Toothbrush

"The cutest stocking stuffer."

sant ambroeus, By Ginori Capuccino Set

sant ambroeus

By Ginori Capuccino Set

"I'm imagining morning coffee at home with these beautiful porcelain cappuccino cups and saucers."

Eliza wears gray trousers, a corset top, and ivory shoulder bag.

saksfifthavenue,

Parfums de Marly

Valaya Eau de Parfum

"I've been using Parfums de Marly's Delina eau de parfum for a little over a year now and have never received so many compliments from complete strangers. One of my co-workers had this Valaya scent on her desk for a while, and I'd always test it out—I fell in love. Though I'd never give up Delina, I'm dying to get my hands on a bottle of my own of Valaya. It never hurts to switch things up, especially with two truly gorgeous scents."

Pillbox

"Mains de Vapeur is a truly incredible hat maker out of New York City. The designer, Mariela Alexandra, makes every hat by hand and has an eye for the elegant things in life. Though I want one for myself, I also would love to give these as gifts—they're so unique and special."

Jamie schneider portrait.

J.Hannah, East West Signet

J.Hannah

East West Signet

"I had a favorite signet ring, lost it, and may or may not have shed a tear when I realized it was missing. I think it’s finally time to replace the heirloom, and what better time than the holidays to gift yourself with something sparkly? I love the classic, sleek face of this east-west signet, and the yellow-gold finish reminds me of the pinky ring my grandfather (who was always dressed to the nines) wore every day."

Retrospect

"I clearly have jewelry on the brain this holiday season, as Merit’s gorgeous new fragrance was inspired by vintage gems. It even comes in a very chic velvet watch box! I usually don’t love powdery florals, but Retrospect has a base of vanilla and musk that give it a warm, seductive quality. Aila Morin, Merit’s CMO, dubs it a cross between 'clean laundry' and 'sexy gourmand,' and I totally agree with that call. Yes, I already have (and love!) the fragrance, but I now want an additional five bottles to gift to my loved ones for a shared scent experience. Call it the beauty-editor version of friendship bracelets." 

Ally wears a black top and ivory bow in her hair.

The Complete System

Olive and June

The Gel Mani Complete System

"I love doing my own gel nails, so when I saw that Olive & June launched its own gel nail system, I had to try it. The verdict is that anyone who loves doing their own nails will be thrilled to receive this as a gift. It's super easy to use and comes with everything you need, and there are tons of polish shades to choose from."

The Holiday Collection

Avaline Wine

The Holiday Collection

"Avaline wines are chic and recognizable, which makes them super giftable. The brand just released its holiday collection, which features five new wines you can only get in the collection. As far as wine gifts go, this one is particularly thoughtful and special."

Nikki Chwatt is an associate fashion editor based in New York City. She joined Who What Wear in 2024 after writing fashion, beauty, and lifestyle content for WWD, Well+Good, Editorialist, and more. With a passion for personal style and the creativity that comes with it, one of Chwatt's goals is to help others understand that there is no such thing as a “good” or “bad” style; it’s just about putting an outfit together that makes you feel confident in yourself. When she's not writing, you can find her taking a Pilates class, reading a powerful romance novel, or exploring a new wellness spot in Manhattan.

Read Entire Article