A spouse's dilemma on whether to secretly pay off the couple's mortgage with a gift from a wealthy relative has provoked a flurry of opinions online.
The original poster (OP), writing under the username Matt_Kenseth, shared this week that his already rich relative just became "extremely wealthy" from a business deal and offered to pay off the remaining $250,000 on the OP's mortgage.
While the OP sees the offer as a financial relief, his wife refuses to accept the money, believing that they should not take handouts and should continue to work for everything they have.
Diverting Payments
The husband, who earns three times his wife's salary and manages most of their finances, believes his idea could have long-term benefits. Instead of telling her, he considers accepting the money in secret while continuing to divert their usual mortgage payments into a brokerage account.
The OP's concern is whether hiding the decision would be wrong, even if it benefits them both financially.
The response from Reddit was sharply divided amid more than 900 comments.
Some users saw deception as the biggest issue, while others questioned whether the wife's stance was fair, given the monetary opportunity.
Others suggested that the OP should reconsider the impact of accepting such a large sum from a relative, as it could come with expectations or future obligations.
"Hiding things from your wife when she explicitly stated her opinion would make you [wrong], a user wrote, "But your wife forcing you to refuse life-changing, no-strings-attached money from a wealthy relative also makes her [wrong].
'Take the money'
"You have the right to accept that money, but you can't lie to her. If your wife is too proud, give me your relative's number."
Another person pointed out the potential risks, saying, "The only issue I could see is if this relative tends to make demands once they gave a gift. Like now they want to be part of their lives in a new way."
One user strongly opposed OP's approach, writing, "I get it, and I 100% think you should take the money, but first, have a long talk with your wife."
How Financial Secrecy Affects Relationships
Financial disagreements are a common issue in marriage and secrecy about monetary decisions can lead to deeper conflicts.
A Newsweek article explains that financial transparency is essential in long-term relationships, as trust is difficult to rebuild once broken. The article suggests that couples should approach financial discussions as a partnership, focusing on shared goals rather than personal philosophies.
A Univest article on financial conflict raises the importance of discussing major money decisions openly and honestly.
The article advises that hiding financial information or making major decisions without a partner's knowledge can lead to serious trust issues, even if the decision benefits both individuals.
The Bigger Issue
Some Reddit critics argued that the OP's issue is about more than money—it's about trust. Others questioned whether pride should prevent a couple from accepting help when it could improve their financial future.
While opinions varied, most agreed that transparency should come before any decision, especially one that impacts both partners.
Newsweek has contacted Matt_Kenseth for comment via Reddit.
Newsweek's "What Should I Do?" offers expert advice to readers. If you have a personal dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money and work, and your story could be featured on WSID at Newsweek.
To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.
English (US) ·